Wayback Burgers’ Big Way Burger Versus Big Mac Taste Test

Courtesy of Wayback Burgers

Wayback Burgers just lately unveiled its McDonald’s-trolling tackle the Large Mac, the Big Way. (The announcement mentioned it’s a “remake of a mediocre burger made by the most important clown within the enterprise.”) McDonald’s and Wayback are two very totally different chains, even when they each sling burgers. Most significantly, Wayback is fast casual, not fast food. It would seem to be a small factor, however it’s vital. You pay extra and anticipate higher at a quick informal institution.

Nonetheless, I wished to know the way these dueling burgers stacked up towards one another. Is the Large Manner genuinely doing an excellent job aping the Large Mac? Whether it is, which is best? I did what anybody would do once they’re paid to consider these deeply essential matters: I attempted them facet by facet.

Now the standards are apparent. The Big Mac is likely one of the most iconic quick meals menu gadgets in existence. It has its personal track! It is not a jingle for the restaurant however for that actual burger. Due to that little ditty, everybody is aware of what’s on a Large Mac. It should not be onerous to recreate. They wrote a track to recollect the recipe. So, let’s use the track as a information to see how Wayback carried out and if being first means being finest.

Big Way Big Mac burger
That is the Large Manner Burger on the left and a Large Mac on the suitable. | Photograph by Dustin Nelson for Thrillist

Two All-Beef Patties

We’re beginning on the high of the track. Preserving in thoughts that that is quick informal versus quick meals, It should not be a good combat at any stage of the jingle. Nonetheless, we begin. 

I’m not excited by the standard of the meat at Wayback. It is not retaining tempo with quick informal opponents like Culver’s, Five Guys, or Smashburger right here. Nonetheless, biting in facet by facet drives residence how flimsy the patty is at McDonald’s. It feels nearly flavorless in comparison with Wayback’s beef, and it positively lacks that charred taste. Neither patty is especially juicy, however the McDonald’s patties are outright dry. I’m dying for just a little extra particular sauce to assist me get it down. Wayback’s meat is not unhealthy, however the scales tip primarily as a result of McDonald’s simply is not reducing it right here.

Level: Wayback (I am giving out factors, I suppose)

big vs big mac
Below the hood of the McDonald’s Large Mac. | Photograph by Dustin Nelson for Thrillist

Particular Sauce

Wayback’s “particular sauce” is a Thousand Island dressing that’s creamier and fewer candy than the sauce from the Golden Arches. You most likely aren’t ordering a Large Mac if the Thousand Island on a burger repulses you, however you must deeply respect salad dressing as a burger condiment while you order the Large Manner. There’s plenty of sauce on there. That is an excellent factor as a result of the less-sweet profile on the Large Manner enhances the burger properly. Additionally, once more, the Large Mac would have benefited from extra sauce to steadiness out the dryness of the meat.

Level: Wayback


Okay. This can be a little bit of a bizarre one. It could come all the way down to desire, however the shredded lettuce at McDonald’s offers the Large Mac a pleasant crunchy texture. In most different situations, the big leaves of lettuce Wayback drops on the burger could be my desire, however McDonald’s has that lettuce texture all the way down to a science, even when it is 99% texture and 1% taste. They have to know that as a result of the elements checklist on this McDonald’s page doesn’t observe the jingle and calls it “crisp lettuce.”

You anticipated McDonald’s to get shut out after I began doling out factors. Nicely, it is a sport.

Level: McDonald’s


It is not simply in regards to the placement of the cheese. I used to be actually looking out to verify McDonald’s did not neglect the cheese completely. I’ve obtained a complete pile of images of the Large Mac, and I do not assume you may see cheese in any of them. Wayback’s American cheese is melted completely and nails what you need from a Large Mac. Additionally, the McDonald’s web page that lists “crisp lettuce” calls the cheese “processed cheddar cheese,” which isn’t an appetizing solution to say the burger’s obtained cheese on it.

Level: Wayback


This class was straightforward, regardless that I actually just like the pickles at McDonald’s. That is perhaps extra about nostalgia than something. Nonetheless, the Large Manner has optimum pickle protection. They’re in all places, they usually’re crunchy. They’re good. McDonald’s, properly…

Level: Wayback


Each of those chains should assume I am frightened of onion breath. I’m not scared. Should you say there are onions on this burger, if you are going to sing about these onions, you higher give me some onions. The onions on each burgers have been tougher to search out than Waldo.

Level: If I have been Gordon Ramsay, I might say no factors. Get the hell out of right here.

big mac vs big way burgers
Below the hood of Wayback’s Large Manner burger. | Photograph by Dustin Nelson for Thrillist

Sesame Seed Bun

Wayback creates a fairly devoted adaptation of the Large Mac on the entire. Nonetheless, there’s a level of divergence right here. It’s like the fashionable Westworld versus the Michael Crichton-directed 1973 Westworld film. Positive the film is perhaps the unique, however nobody is debating which is best.

As a substitute of the triple stack of bread that McDonald’s serves, Wayback offers you a brioche bun. Only a bun. No third slice. No sesame seeds. Nonetheless, it’s painfully apparent that the standard of the bread is way larger at Wayback. That’d be the case even when the sesame seed bun from McDonald’s wasn’t a bit stale, and it was.

Level: Wayback, even when I’m lacking about 70 sesame seeds right here.


Clearly, Wayback is costlier. It got here in at about $8.50. The Large Mac in my neighborhood price me $5.55. Once more, we’re taking a look at quick informal versus quick meals. Anticipate all the things to be marginally costlier. Nonetheless, the ethical of the story right here is that you just’re getting what you pay for.

Level: McDonald’s, I suppose. I most likely shouldn’t give some extent for this. Too late now. 


Oof. I do know you may costume up a Large Mac to look good in an image, however the one which I obtained just isn’t a good-looking sandwich. The Large Mac seems grim subsequent to the Large Manner.

Level: Wayback

Is it a Devoted Cowl?

There are variations between the 2, however they’re primarily about making the Large Manner style higher. Wayback might place the Large Manner as a troll, however the reality is that imitation is the sincerest type of flattery. This can be a tribute to what is perhaps essentially the most iconic quick meals merchandise in American historical past.

Setting Every thing Apart

Actually, when you’re sitting all the way down to scarf down a Large Manner, you may not be all that involved with the breakdown or if it is a devoted homage. Here is what issues: It is a strong burger. It is higher than a Large Mac, and it is a legit contender for the most effective burger on the Wayback menu. It is completely value ordering. The place it comes up quick are the precise spots the place different Wayback burgers come up quick when in comparison with the titans of quick informal burgers just like the ButterBurger or the Traditional Smash Burger.

Should you’re craving a Large Mac, you may be very happy to have spent the additional couple of bucks on a Large Manner.

Need extra Thrillist? Observe us on Instagram, Twitter, Pinterest, YouTube, TikTok, and Snapchat.

Dustin Nelson is a Senior Staff Writer at Thrillist. Observe Dustin Nelson on Twitter.

Source link

Wayback Burgers’ Big Way Burger Versus Big Mac Taste Test

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Scroll to top